Retain not indexing new items since upgrade

Everything looked fine during the upgrade to SOLR9 and 24.1 back in April. Just now I happened to be searching for something and realized that no new emails after April are showing up on a search. They do exist on a "Browse" however, so database is working, but Indexing hasn't updated since then. I can't find any obvious errors. Anyone know what might cause this to (not) happen?